Why Bad Weather Matters for Laser Weapons

Introduction

Bad weather matters for laser weapons because a laser has to deliver enough concentrated energy through real air, not through a laboratory vacuum. Fog, rain, sea spray, dust, smoke, humidity, turbulence and the laser’s own heating of the air can all reduce the energy that reaches the target, spread the beam, or force the weapon to dwell on the target for longer than the engagement allows. This does not make high-energy lasers useless: modern systems use wavelength selection, beam control and adaptive optics to improve performance in some degraded conditions. But it does mean they are not all-weather replacements for guns and missiles. The key military question is not whether the laser can fire, but whether enough useful energy reaches the right aim point, for long enough, under the air conditions at that moment. The US Government Accountability Office notes that weather such as fog and storms can make some directed-energy weapons less effective, while the Congressional Research Service warns that rain, fog and obscurants can limit laser range and beam quality.[GAO]gao.govScience & Tech Spotlight: Directed Energy WeaponsScience & Tech Spotlight: Directed Energy WeaponsMay 25, 2023 — They also generally have a shorter range than conventional weapons, an…Published: May 25, 2023

Fog, rain, aerosols and beam loss

A high-energy laser weapon works by focusing light onto a vulnerable point on a target. Anything in the air that absorbs or scatters that light reduces the beam’s useful intensity before it arrives. Molecular absorption by gases such as water vapour and carbon dioxide can remove energy at particular wavelengths. Aerosols such as sea salt, dust, soot, smoke, pollution and suspended droplets scatter light out of the intended beam path. A Naval Postgraduate School study on directed-energy weapons describes atmospheric absorption, scattering, turbulence and thermal blooming as core propagation problems because they reduce the strength and quality of the beam at the target, not merely its neatness as an optical line.[calhoun.nps.edu]calhoun.nps.eduDirect-energy weapons: invisible and invincible?August 13, 2007 — by BM Deveci · 2007 · Cited by 15 —… Thermal Blooming. Thermal blooming is distortion of a propagating beam c…Published: August 13, 2007

Fog is especially troublesome because it is made of many small water droplets suspended in air. Those droplets do not need to block the beam like a wall; scattering and absorption are enough to lower the irradiance that reaches the target. In dense fog, haze or cloud, the weapon may still emit a beam, but the beam arriving at the target can be too weak, too spread out or too unstable to heat the intended point quickly. This is why two common simplifications are both wrong: “lasers cannot work in fog or rain” is too absolute, but “lasers travel at light speed, so weather does not matter” ignores the physics of propagation. The real answer depends on wavelength, power, aperture, range, droplet size, aerosol density, target material and required dwell time. The US Army has argued publicly that high-energy lasers can be developed to penetrate some fog, rain and dust through beam control and adaptive optics, but that claim is best read as a rejection of an absolute myth rather than proof of all-weather lethality.[Army]army.mildeveloping lasers that pierce fog dust to destroy targetsArmy developing lasers that pierce fog, dust to destroy targets23 Oct 2017 — A lot of people think that high-energy lasers, or HELs…

Rain is different from fog because the water is concentrated into larger drops with more space between them. A beam can pass between drops, but heavy rain still adds absorption, scattering and rapidly changing distortions. Sea spray creates a related maritime problem: droplets and salt particles are common close to the ocean surface, exactly where ship-defence lasers may need to engage small boats, drones or low-flying threats. CRS notes that lasers may be affected by rain, fog and obscurants, and also highlights water vapour as an important issue for naval laser weapons; designers can reduce some losses by choosing wavelengths near atmospheric “windows”, but they cannot make the atmosphere disappear.[EveryCRSReport]everycrsreport.comHTML22. Congressional Research Service 17. Department of Defense Directed Energy Weapons… rain or fog, preventing lasers…

The practical consequence is that laser range is not a single clean number. A system that can engage a fragile drone at a useful distance in clear air may have a much shorter effective range in haze, smoke, dust or sea mist. The same system may perform well against one target type at short range but struggle against a harder, faster or more distant target under worse atmospheric extinction. This is why credible laser-weapon claims need an environmental envelope, not just an output-power figure or a video of a shoot-down.

Thermal blooming in plain language

Thermal blooming is what happens when the laser changes the air it is trying to pass through. Some of the beam’s energy is absorbed along the path, warming the air. Warmer air is less dense, and that density change alters the refractive index of the air. In plain terms, the beam can create a weak, shifting lens in front of itself. That lens can defocus the beam, increase the spot size at the target and reduce the concentrated power that makes a laser weapon effective. Lincoln Laboratory describes thermal blooming as beam spreading caused when some of the beam energy is absorbed by the medium through which it travels; if uncorrected, this spreading can significantly reduce the effectiveness of high-power lasers used as directed-energy weapons.[archive.ll.mit.edu]archive.ll.mit.eduOpen source on mit.edu.

This matters because many laser weapons rely on dwell time: they must keep enough energy on a small aim point long enough to damage a sensor, casing, control surface, motor, warhead section or drone structure. If thermal blooming spreads the beam, the target receives less intense heating at the point that matters. CRS describes the problem in operational terms: a laser firing in the same direction can heat the air, defocus the beam and reduce its ability to disable the target. This is particularly relevant when a target is flying almost directly towards the laser, because the beam keeps passing through much the same air path. A crossing target may be less punishing because the beam path changes as the target moves across the field of view.[EveryCRSReport]everycrsreport.comHTML22. Congressional Research Service 17. Department of Defense Directed Energy Weapons… rain or fog, preventing lasers…

Thermal blooming becomes more important as laser powers rise, but the relationship is not as simple as “more power always fixes the problem”. More power can increase energy on target, yet it can also deposit more heat into the air along the way. The weapon must manage the trade-off between output power, beam diameter, focus, atmospheric absorption, wind and the time needed to achieve the desired effect. Naval Postgraduate School research notes that wind can influence blooming by cooling or moving the heated air column, while modelling studies of high-energy laser propagation treat extinction, turbulence, platform jitter and blooming as linked factors that determine on-target irradiance.[calhoun.nps.edu]calhoun.nps.eduOpen source on nps.edu.

Adaptive optics can help, but it is not magic. Adaptive optics uses deformable mirrors and wavefront sensing to correct distortions in the optical path. Lincoln Laboratory experiments on thermal blooming found that adaptive optics can compensate for strong blooming under some conditions, while also showing that realistic hardware, nonlinear effects and atmospheric conditions create limits. The useful lesson for laser weapons is balanced: beam-control technology can recover performance, but there are regimes where the atmosphere and the correction system still interact in ways that reduce delivered energy.[archive.ll.mit.edu]archive.ll.mit.eduThermal-Blooming Laboratory ExperimentsThermal-Blooming Laboratory Experiments

Why clear line of sight is not enough

Laser weapons are line-of-sight systems, but “line of sight” does not mean “clean energy delivery”. The UK Ministry of Defence describes DragonFire as a line-of-sight weapon able to engage visible targets, and says the system has achieved high-power firing against aerial targets at the Hebrides Range. Leonardo, one of the DragonFire partners, also stresses the difficulty of maintaining precision while the target is moving, the platform is moving and atmospheric interference lies between them. These statements capture the central limitation: visibility is only the beginning of the engagement problem.[GOV.UK]GOV.UKAdvanced future military laser achieves UK firstAdvanced future military laser achieves UK first

Three requirements have to line up. First, the system must see, track and identify the target well enough to aim. Second, the beam must propagate through the atmosphere with enough focus and intensity. Third, the laser must dwell on a vulnerable point long enough to achieve the intended effect. Bad weather can interfere with all three at once: fog and rain can degrade sensors, aerosols can reduce transmission, turbulence can move or blur the beam, and manoeuvring targets can break the dwell time needed for a thermal kill. The issue is therefore not just whether a target is visible to an operator, but whether the whole sensor-to-shooter chain can maintain a useful aim point through a disturbed optical path.[calhoun.nps.edu]calhoun.nps.eduDirect-energy weapons: invisible and invincible?August 13, 2007 — by BM Deveci · 2007 · Cited by 15 —… Thermal Blooming. Thermal blooming is distortion of a propagating beam c…Published: August 13, 2007

Turbulence explains why even clear-looking air can be optically difficult. Temperature and density variations change the air’s refractive index along the path, bending parts of the beam wavefront in slightly different ways. This can make the beam wander, scintillate or spread before it reaches the target. Adaptive optics is intended to measure and correct this distortion, but directed-energy use is demanding because the atmosphere, target and weapon platform may all be moving in real time. A 2022 review in the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics notes that adaptive optics is valuable for directed energy when higher-order aberrations are significant in the optical path.[AIAA Journal]arc.aiaa.orgAIAA JournalAdaptive Optics for Directed Energy: Fundamentals and…by RB Holmes · 2022 · Cited by 28 — Adaptive optics are beneficial f…

This is why atmospheric limits affect tactics as much as physics. A ship or ground vehicle carrying a laser may still need conventional interceptors for heavy rain, dense smoke, long-range engagements or hardened targets. Conversely, a laser may be highly attractive when the air is clear enough, the target is close enough and the intended effect is against a drone, exposed sensor, small-boat component or fragile munition. The atmosphere does not simply decide whether a laser weapon works; it helps decide when the laser is the right defensive layer.

The planning risk is overconfidence

The most important operational risk is treating a laser as a cheap missile rather than as a weather-sensitive optical system. A laser shot may cost little in electrical energy compared with an interceptor missile, but the weapon’s real combat value depends on range, target type, target aspect, atmospheric transmission, beam quality and dwell time. CRS explicitly warns that rain, fog and obscurants can limit range and beam quality, while GAO states that weather conditions can make certain directed-energy weapons less effective. Those are not minor caveats; they define where the weapon can be relied upon.[EveryCRSReport]everycrsreport.comHTML22. Congressional Research Service 17. Department of Defense Directed Energy Weapons… rain or fog, preventing lasers…

The second risk is that the atmosphere can become a countermeasure. Natural conditions such as cloud cover, dust, pollution, mist and rainfall increase absorption and scattering, while longer distances give the beam more atmosphere to cross. Work on counter-directed-energy measures identifies atmospheric extinction as a protective factor and notes that unmanned aircraft may benefit from cloud, dust, polluted air, mist or rainfall when facing high-energy laser threats. That does not make weather a guaranteed shield, but it shows why an adversary may prefer routes, timing or obscurants that degrade laser performance.[Naval Postgraduate School]nps.eduOpen source on nps.edu.

The third risk is testing optimism. A successful shoot-down in clear, instrumented range conditions proves something important, but it does not prove the same performance in sea spray, desert dust, urban smoke, low cloud or rapidly changing boundary-layer turbulence. For any announced laser system, the useful questions are not only its power level and cost per shot. They are also the environmental limits: visibility, humidity, aerosol load, precipitation rate, range, target speed, target surface, platform motion and minimum dwell time for the intended effect.

For directed-energy weapons, bad weather is not a footnote. It is part of the engagement geometry. Lasers are most credible when treated as conditional, high-precision defensive tools whose performance depends on the air between weapon and target. That makes atmospheric sensing, beam control, weather modelling and fallback weapons central to any realistic introduction of laser weapons into military service.

Amazon book picks

Further Reading

Books and field guides related to Why Bad Weather Matters for Laser Weapons. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.

Book

Directed Energy Weapons

By Bahman Zohuri

Explains high-energy laser weapon operation and practical environmental limitations.

See on Amazon

Book

Introduction to adaptive optics

By Robert K. Tyson

Helps explain atmospheric distortion mitigation in laser systems.

See on Amazon

Book

The Pentagon's Brain

By Annie Jacobsen

Discover the definitive history of DARPA, the Defense Advanced Research Project Agency, in this Pulitzer Prize finalist from the author o...

See on Amazon

Book

Laser beam propagation through random media

By Unknown author

Directly covers turbulence, beam spreading, scintillation and atmospheric effects on lasers.

See on Amazon

Browse more on Amazon: Directed Energy Weapons to adaptive optics books The Pentagon's Brain

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

eBay marketplace picks

Marketplace Samples

Example marketplace items related to this page. Use the search link to explore similar finds on eBay.

Shop location

UsingUSA USA USAUKCanadaAustraliaIreland

Example eBay listing

Vintage Vietnam Era Texas Instruments Laser Guided Display Model Kit

SearcheBay.co.uk: military laser display model

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Example eBay listing

MQ-9 Predator B Reaper Hunter Killer Drone USAF UAV Wood Wooden Mahogany Model

SearcheBay.co.uk: military laser display model

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Example eBay listing

Vintage Vietnam Era Texas Instruments Laser Guided Bomb Display Model Kit

SearcheBay.co.uk: military laser display model

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Example eBay listing

USAF Boeing YAL-1A Airborne Laser Edwards AFB Desk Top Model 1/200 SC Airplane

SearcheBay.co.uk: military laser display model

Browse similar oneBay.co.uk

Browse more oneBay.co.uk

Example items shown for inspiration; availability and pricing can change. Branchoria may earn a commission if you purchase through outbound eBay links.

Endnotes

1. Source: gao.gov
Title: Science & Tech Spotlight: Directed Energy Weapons
Link:https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-23-106717

Published: May 25, 2023

2. Source: everycrsreport.com
Link:https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2024-07-11_R46925_4c1e5a38ad3d6906a3ea03e0972e08d8979659f3.html

3. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Title: Direct-energy weapons: invisible and invincible?
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstream/handle/10945/3311/07Sep_Deveci.pdf?sequence=1

Published: August 13, 2007

4. Source: army.mil
Title: developing lasers that pierce fog dust to destroy targets
Link:https://www.army.mil/article/195650/army_developing_lasers_that_pierce_fog_dust_to_destroy_targets

5. Source: arc.aiaa.org
Link:https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/10.2514/1.J061766

6. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/journalarchives05-1.html

7. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol05_no1/5.1.7.compensatedlaser.pdf

8. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstreams/aab53d9d-9919-467e-8021-3111fccffdd3/download

9. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Title: Thermal-Blooming Laboratory Experiments
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol05_no1/5.1.8.thermalblooming.pdf

10. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol05_no2/5.2.5.scaledblooming.pdf

11. Source: GOV.UK
Title: Advanced future military laser achieves UK first
Link:https://www.gov.uk/government/news/advanced-future-military-laser-achieves-uk-first

12. Source: uk.leonardo.com
Title: Dragon Fire – Laser Directed Energy Weapon
Link:https://uk.leonardo.com/en/innovation/dragonfire

13. Source: nps.edu
Link:https://nps.edu/documents/10180/142489929/JDE_7-2_Johnson.pdf

14. Source: nps.edu
Link:https://nps.edu/web/research/-/propagation-of-high-energy-lasers-for-various-wavelengths-power-levels-and-atmospheric-conditions-2018

15. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Title: 16Jun Collins Joseph
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstream/handle/10945/49439/16Jun_Collins_Joseph.pdf?sequence=1

16. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/5a81dcfa-356e-40c0-8b4c-021b96ed7860/content

17. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/3f7b07df-d919-49c7-90bb-8c632e71d5b7/content

18. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Title: 95Dec Ramos
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstream/handle/10945/7476/95Dec_Ramos.pdf?sequence=1

19. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/132ae2fa-1efe-47f7-af14-93673e15c305/content

20. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Title: 16Jun Valiani Joshua
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstream/handle/10945/49406/16Jun_Valiani_Joshua.pdf?sequence=1

21. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Title: 13Jun SEA Cohort 19 Team Bravo
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/bitstream/handle/10945/34734/13Jun_SEA_Cohort_19_Team_Bravo.pdf?sequence=1

22. Source: calhoun.nps.edu
Link:https://calhoun.nps.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/8c483800-5a0f-4b01-bc3a-ad70fe7ae5d0/content

23. Source: nps.edu
Title: SEA 19B DEW Final Report
Link:https://nps.edu/documents/105988579/106076800/SEA-19B_DEW_Final_Report.pdf

24. Source: faculty.nps.edu
Title: english single word freqs.txt
Link:https://faculty.nps.edu/ncrowe/coursematerials/english_single_word_freqs.txt

25. Source: everycrsreport.com
Link:https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/2022-09-13_R46925_3cec298682f62bdf9aad62dc48a2a063e1e6556e.html

26. Source: everycrsreport.com
Link:https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R46925.html

27. Source: everycrsreport.com
Link:https://www.everycrsreport.com/files/20120614_R41526_ce8f170edaf66a26b5d6441bf2b2e219d8622dbf.html

28. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol05_no1/5.1.1.opticsresearch.pdf

29. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol03_no2/3.2.3.beampathconditioning.pdf

30. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol02_no1/2.1.8.adaptiveoptics.pdf

31. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/pdf/vol05_no1/5.1.6.swatwavefront.pdf

32. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Title: journalarchives05 2
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/journalarchives05-2.html

33. Source: archive.ll.mit.edu
Link:https://archive.ll.mit.edu/publications/journal/journalarchives.html

34. Source: dspace.mit.edu
Title: 31359954 MIT
Link:https://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/35978/31359954-MIT.pdf

35. Source: gao.gov
Link:https://www.gao.gov/video/directed-energy-weapons-dod-should-focus-transition-planning

36. Source: airpower.airforce.gov.au
Title: airforce.gov.au Directed Energy Weapons
Link:https://airpower.airforce.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-03/BPAF03_Directed-Energy-Weapons.pdf

37. Source: hsdl.org
Link:https://www.hsdl.org/c/view?docid=893273

38. Source: Wikipedia
Title: Laser weapon
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_weapon

39. Source: dictionary.cambridge.org
Link:https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/high

40. Source: lockheedmartin.com
Link:https://www.lockheedmartin.com/en-us/capabilities/directed-energy.html

Additional References

41. Source: youtube.com
Title: The Pentagon’s Laser Problem and The Company To Fix it
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iyBkTwFyIqY

42. Source: youtube.com
Title: Iron Beam In Fog: Can Laser Weapons Work Without Visibility?
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J2NJLBVER8

43. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235041191_Atmospheric_Propagation_of_High_Energy_Lasers_Modeling_Simulation_Tracking_and_Control

44. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/307435395_Laser_Weapons

45. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/403676537Laser-Based_Directed_Energy_Weapons_Technological_Capabilities_Material_Interaction_and_Strategic[Deployment

46. Source: researchgate.net
Link:https://www.researchgate.net/publication/399863884_Laser-Based_Directed_Energy_Weapons_Technological_Capabilities_Material_Interaction_and_Strategic_Deployment_Pathways

47. Source: navysbir.us
Link:https://navysbir.us/n13_1/N131-076.htm

48. Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/avweek/posts/as-the-us-air-force-comes-within-weeks-of-the-first-operational-laser-weapons-th/10157699975222200/

49. Source: scienceandglobalsecurity.org
Link:https://scienceandglobalsecurity.org/archive/sgs18stupl.pdf

50. Source: market.us
Link:https://market.us/report/directed-energy-weapons-market/